BBC interviewee’s support for Greta Berlin’s antisemitic videos

As readers will no doubt remember, the BBC World Service saw fit to broadcast an interview with Gilad Atzmon on its ‘Weekend’ programme on October 14th 2012, in which the host Julian Worricker declared himself to be “intrigued” by the proudly antisemitic, Holocaust-denying jazz musician. Worricker even posted a photo of himself and Atzmon on the BBC World Service’s Facebook wall. 

Atzmon has not been shy about adding his voice to the fray which ensued after Greta Berlin of the ‘Free Gaza Movement’ posted a video claiming that “Zionists operated the concentration camps” on the organisation’s official Twitter account.

(If you have not been keeping up with that rather tangled chain of events, it is documented here – part 1 – and here – part 2 – by Avi Mayer and is well worth reading in full.)

The Greta Berlin story broke on September 30th: two weeks before Atzmon’s World Service interview. By October 7th, Atzmon had come out in support of Berlin and her posting of the video, writing on his own blog:

“A few days ago Greta Berlin had been subject to a vile Israeli and Zionist smear campaign following her facebook post containing the following message: “Zionists operated the concentration camps and helped murder millions of innocent Jews”. ” …

“Zionists and Hasbara agents were very quick to slander Berlin. They tagged her as an ‘anti Semite’ and a ‘Holocaust denier’. But clearly there is no Holocaust denial in Berlin’s message..” ….

 “The meaning of it all is pretty simple. As I disclose in my latest book The Wandering Who, there is a devastating continuum between hard core Zionism, Israeli Hasbara and the Jewish so-called ‘left’. Unfortunately, some Palestinians also operate as Sabbath Goyim. And they better be exposed [sic].”

In other words, Atzmon regards attempts by those in the world of pro-Palestinian activism to clean up their movement’s act and dissociate it from racism and Holocaust denial as a “Zionist plot”. 

That information was available to BBC researchers and to Julian Worricker – who claimed during the interview to have read “both critics and supporters” of Atzmon – a full week before the programme was broadcast. 

And yet, despite Atzmon’s infamous history and his open support for a woman who promoted antisemitic material on the internet (including a 1943 Nazi propaganda film), Worricker elected to go ahead with the interview, not only failing to challenge any of Atzmon’s bizarre statements, but also with the dumbed-down presentation of his guest as a mere “controversial public critic of Israel”.

The employment of racism and Holocaust denial in order to delegitimize a nation for political ends does not fall into the category of ‘criticism’ and Atzmon’s rantings go far beyond Worricker’s theme of “music and politics”. 

More recently, on October 19th, Atzmon published another predictably odious piece – entitled “Jewish Domination? Occupation More Likely” and cross-posted at ‘Countercurrents‘ – in which he wrote of those opposing antisemitism and Holocaust denial:

“The recent attack on Free Gaza’s Greta Berlin and Colonel Ann Wright suggests that we have crossed a red line — Jewish domination within the Palestinian solidarity movement belongs to the past. We are now, it seems, under Zionist occupation, and we are subject to all the symptoms of Israeli abuse and Zionist brutality. The expulsions, the exclusions and the cleansings that are inherent within Zionism, Israeli and Jewish politics, are now alive and kicking within the Palestinian solidarity movement itself. ” ….

“The message here is clear – some elements within the Palestinian solidarity movement have obviously adopted the most repellent and brutal Zionist symptoms, and we are now engaged, caught up in, and beset by a sinister series of expulsions, purges, crude witch hunts, exclusions, smears, character defamations and cleansings.”

I would be very interested to hear whether Julian Worricker really thinks that anti-Semitism and Holocaust denial constitute “criticism” of Israel (or anything else) and if he still stands by the decision to give air-time to a man who thinks they have a place in the pro-Palestinian movement. Mr Worricker is invited to contribute his thoughts to the discussion in the comments below. 

21 comments on “BBC interviewee’s support for Greta Berlin’s antisemitic videos

  1. I’m sure he’ll come on here soon – meanwhile he’s probably busy and ‘intrigued’, by meetings and conversations with David Duke and Nick Griffin, both of whom he knows to be controversial but whose speeches and writings he’s spent some time looking through.

    Oh, what you mean he’s NOT having them on his show? What a surprised.

  2. Surely the only surprise can be that Worricker (and others of his ilk) haven’t attempted (and might have succeeded had they asked) in interviewing Abu Hamza – “controversial and interesting” are the euphemisms that spring to mind.

  3. Pingback: GayPatriot » Watcher of Weasels Nominations — 10.24.12 Edition

  4. Pingback: This Week’s Watcher’s Council Nominations |

  5. Pingback: Trevor Loudon's New Zeal Blog

  6. Pingback: Watcher’s Council Nominations – Horses & Bayonets Edition | Independent Sentinel

  7. Pingback: Watcher’s Council Nominations – Horses And Bayonets Edition | askmarion

  8. Pingback: Bookworm Room » Watcher’s Council submissions for October 24, 2012

  9. Pingback: BBC World Service programme on Jews from Arab lands – part 1 | BBC Watch

  10. Pingback: BBC World Service hosts antisemite Gilad Atzmon | BBC Watch

  11. Pingback: Horses And Bayonets |

  12. Pingback: GayPatriot » Watcher of Weasels — Winners 10.26.12

  13. Pingback: Trevor Loudon's New Zeal Blog

  14. Pingback: Watcher’s Council Winners! | Independent Sentinel

  15. Pingback: The Council Has Spoken!! This Week’s Watchers Council Winners 10.26.12 | askmarion

  16. Pingback: Bookworm Room » The Council has spoken — October 26, 2012

  17. Pingback: The Council Has Spoken!! This Week’s Watchers Council Winners | Virginia Right!

  18. Pingback: Sandy the Storm in Blogposts |

  19. Pingback: BBC’s Wyre Davies plays wingman to anti-Israel NGOs | BBC Watch

  20. Pingback: BBC World Service promotes Gilad Atzmon – again | BBC Watch

Comments are closed.