BBC captions photo of tourist attraction as “army position”

An article appearing on the Middle East page of the BBC News website on June 11th 2013 related to the withdrawal of Austrian members of UNDOF from the Golan Heights.

Austria UNDOF withdrawal

The article is reasonably impartial, but includes two inaccuracies. It describes the Quneitra crossing as:

“..the only open crossing between Syria and the Israeli-controlled Golan Heights”

Quneitra cannot be accurately described as an “open crossing” as it is used on a regular basis only by members of UN forces and – with prior co-ordination and after the issue of the appropriate permits – by members of the Golan Druze community studying in Syria. It is also used on occasion by Druze from the Golan villages getting married in Syria or Syrian Druze getting married in the Golan, by Druze pilgrims to Syria and as a point of entry for the trade of apples grown in the Druze villages, with the coordination of the Red Cross. Tourists or civilians who do not belong to the Druze community cannot use the crossing. 

The article also states:

“Syria’s deployment of tanks in the demilitarised zone violates ceasefire agreements in place since the Arab-Israeli war of 1973..”

Whilst the Yom Kippur war certainly began in October 1973, the ceasefire agreements only came into being at the end of May 1974

On the Middle East homepage, the article was presented together with two ‘related articles’, one of which is the BBC’s profile of the Golan Heights.

GH profile on HP

We have already addressed the subject of inaccuracies in the “overview” section of that profile here, but in the “timeline” section we also find an inaccurately captioned photograph.

Bental bbc GH profile

That photograph was in fact taken at Mount Bental, which is not “an army position” as claimed by the BBC, but a tourist attraction run by Kibbutz Merom Golan.  The metal cut-out soldier on the left of the BBC’s picture can be seen in the photograph below from the opposite angle – with the site’s decidedly un-military coffee shop in the background.  

pic bental

8 comments on “BBC captions photo of tourist attraction as “army position”

  1. Well spotted Hadar.

    Duvidl guesses you took the second very inviting photo of the coffee shop and cutout, while the first one of the cutout and IDF personnel enjoying the view was, doubtless, taken by Palywood’s finest – maybe working for the BBC picture desk.

  2. I never heard of anyone with the minimal knowledge of the Golan who doesn’t know Coffee Anan apart from the BBC “we know all” cretins.

    Even for the most superficially interested tourist
    The Coffee Anan restaurant is located on top of Mount Bental and is famous for being the highest restaurant in Israel at 1,165 meters above sea level. Coffee Anan is a humorous play on the name of the former Secretary-General of the United Nations, Kofi Anan, as well as fittingly meaning, “Cloud Coffee,” in Hebrew, and indeed one can enjoy coffee on the mountain peak that is covered by fog most of the time.

    • Even with a better label there’s still plenty wrong with the BBC Golan Heights profile. Profilaxis

      Wouldn’t a more neutral label have been on the lines of the Mount Bental lookout, during the Yom Kippur War 1973, the site the site of one of the largest tank battles in history, provides stunning views of Mount Hermon and the Golan? Easy to cut this down for letter limits, if required.

  3. Pingback: Photo caption on BBC Golan Heights profile page corrected | BBC Watch

  4. Hey there just wanted to give you a quick heads
    up. The text in your content seem to be running off the screen in Firefox.

    I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with internet browser compatibility but I thought I’d post to let you know.
    The design look great though! Hope you get the issue resolved soon.

    Cheers

Comments are closed.