BBC News reframes Iranian arms shipment story, censors information

On March 10th a BBC producer made his way to Eilat to cover the story of the weapons shipment seized aboard the Klos-C as it was shown to the media the day after its arrival in Israel’s southern port. 

Klos C tweet Shuval

The report on that topic which appeared on the Middle East page of the BBC News website later that evening is notable for the fact that instead of fully and accurately informing BBC audiences about the details of the weapons shipment itself, it frames the story in very different terms.

On the Middle East homepage the heading linking to the report read “Israel attacks ‘hypocrisy’ over Iran” and, still using the “Israel says” caveat, the subheading informed readers that:

“Prime Minister Netanyahu shows his anger at the West as he unveils a shipment of weapons Israel says were being sent from Iran to Gaza.” [emphasis added]

Klos C art on ME pge 10 3

The article itself is titled “Israel attacks ‘hypocrisy’ of international community on Iran” and it opens with repetitions of the Iranian and Hamas propaganda previously touted by the BBC in earlier reports. Klos C art 10 3

“Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has accused the international community of “hypocrisy” over Iran.

Mr Netanyahu spoke as the Israeli military unveiled what it alleged was a cache of Syrian-made weapons being sent by Iran to militants in the Gaza Strip.

He criticised EU foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton, who visited Tehran at the weekend, for her “smiles and handshakes” with Iran’s leaders.

Iran has dismissed as “failed lies” the accusation it was behind the shipment.

A spokesman for Hamas, the militant Palestinian Islamist movement that governs Gaza, has meanwhile said it is all a “silly joke”.” [emphasis added]

The factual information provided to reporters at the event was condensed by the BBC into two short paragraphs, the wording of which is quite remarkable when one considers that at least one BBC employee saw the forty 302 mm missiles, the 181 Iranian-manufactured 120 mm mortar shells and the 400,000 7.62 mm calibre bullets seized aboard the Klos-C with his own eyes.  

“Israel’s navy seized a Panamanian-flagged vessel, the Klos-C, in the Red Sea off Sudan last Wednesday, and said it was carrying dozens of M-302 rockets, which have a range of 150km to 200km (93-124 miles).

The weapons had been tracked for several months as they were flown from Damascus to Tehran and then taken to a port in southern Iran, it alleged. From there, it added, they were loaded on to the Klos-C, which sailed to Iraq, where containers of cement were added.”

Significantly, BBC audiences are kept entirely in the dark with regard to the information provided to the press which shows that the weapons shipment did indeed come from Iran. The fact that the shipment included Iranian-produced mortars is disappeared entirely from the BBC’s report. The fact that the weapons were concealed under bags of cement marked as being made in Iran and that the containers carrying the arms had unique seals used by the Iranian customs authorities is also not mentioned. 

Klos C customs seal

Reporters were also shown the Klos-C’s paperwork which indicates that 100 numbered containers – including those carrying the weapons – were loaded at the Iranian port of Bandar Abbas (click on the links to see the documents).

Klos C manifest Bandar Abbas

Klos C manifest Bandar Abbas 2

The ship then sailed to Umm Qasr in Iraq, where a further 50 containers were loaded.

Klos C loading Umm Qasr

The ship’s manifest was then altered manually to create the false impression that all 150 containers – including those carrying weapons – had been loaded in Iraq. 

Klos C forged manifest

The BBC, however, has elected to censor all that information and continues to encourage audiences to view the story in terms of competing Israeli and Iranian claims by means of unquestioned promotion of the latter’s propaganda and liberal use of phrases such as “Israel says” and “Israel alleged”.

The rest of the BBC report is devoted to remarks made by the Israeli prime minister at the press conference, with the curious inclusion of a video showing an interview with the EU’s Catherine Ashton during her recent visit to Iran and a link to a previous BBC report from Iran by Lyse Doucet. 

The fact that this BBC report conceals crucial information, and instead seeks to turn readers’ attentions to a version framing the Israeli prime minister’s remarks as the story’s focus, of course actively hinders BBC audiences’ ability to form their own fact-based opinions on the subject of Iran’s policy of arming and financing terrorist organisations in the Middle East and further afield and the implications of that in relation to the ongoing P5+1 negotiations on Iran’s nuclear programme. 

Sadly for BBC audiences however, there is nothing novel about that. Since this story first broke, the BBC’s coverage of it has been notable in that it has consistently tried to distract audiences’ attention from the actual issue of Iranian arms shipments to terrorist organisations by reframing the story to focus on the Gaza Strip, on Iranian denials of involvement and now on the Israeli prime minister’s “anger”. By repeatedly reframing the story and by deliberately omitting crucial information it had at its disposal, the BBC has clearly breached its own editorial guidelines on accuracy and impartiality and failed to meet its public purpose of building “a global understanding of international issues”. 

Related Articles:

BBC employs smoke and mirrors in report on Iranian weapons smuggling ship

Inaccurate map used to illustrate BBC reports on Klos-C weapons interception

BBC News website self-conscripts to ‘Mini Me’ role on Klos-C weapons interception

More BBC amplification of Iranian propaganda on Klos-C story

25 comments on “BBC News reframes Iranian arms shipment story, censors information

    • BBC journalists are just that – journalists. They report on facts. They are not Netanyahu’s PRs. As long as there is no independent investigation proving where the weapons came from, they have to source the info – to Israel.

      • precisely. if there’s no independent verification of their provenience, they must state their source.

        in this case, Israel says…..

        • Ashton’s visit to Teheran is an excellent thing. Iranians are human beings like any of us. Trying to demonise Iran, as far rightist Israeli politicians do, is counter productive.

          • No more than the U.S. State Department who said “Iran’s sponsorship of terrorism overseas underwent “a marked resurgence” in 2012, reaching levels not seen in 20 years, ”
            The year 2012 was … notable in demonstrating a marked resurgence of Iran’s state sponsorship of terrorism,” via Tehran’s elite al Quds force, its intelligence ministry, and Hezbollah, the report said. “Iran and Hezbollah’s terrorist activity has reached a tempo unseen since the 1990s.”

          • Hey sockpuppet, you constantly quote the United Nations as the font of “international law” and defender of Yooman Rites, so read this and choke on it:

            UN Chief Says Rouhani Has Not Increased Freedoms in Iran

            Reuters – Iranian President Hassan Rouhani has failed to fulfill campaign promises to allow greater freedom of expression and there has been a sharp rise in executions since his election, U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said on Tuesday.

            Read full story.
            (You want “independent sources?)

          • He probably hasn’t increased freedom in Iran – and this is not a good thing.

            Has no baring on this article though, does it?

            Why not use this great, independent source for something closer to the point of the article, eh?

            you can do it!

  1. I am wishing so very hard for a great Jewish brain to come forward and sue the BBC out of existence. it is anything but impartial when it comes to all things Jewish/Israel. hitler couldn’t have dreamed of anything better than the BBC.

  2. The BBC has long been a cauldron of misinformation and boias against Israel. Its avowed impartiality is becoming an internations JOKE!!

    • based on what? your say-so?

      you add nothing to the debate, provide no evidence for such an assertion, thus making it pretty worthless

      • What do you “add to the debate”, other than a seemingly endless string of different screen names, simon g, Jmarra, James Smith, Janette S, revolution242.co.sick?

          • ROTFLMFAO!

            You really are taking the pi$$ aren’t you?

            I’m still waiting for you to give us the source of your accusation that the Irgun bombed more than one hotel.

            If you actually read my comments you’d see the sources I refer to…

    • The BBC is watched by millions of Britons every day. Cannot say the same for this website, obviously.

      • Obviously this website is frequented by just one sockpuppet/troll using by now dozens of false screen names and proxies to give the impression that many others share his opinions.

        Considering he/she/it once claimed to have unlimited time and money to dedicate to attempting to disrupt this website one has to wonder whether it’s the very same BBC paying its wages.

  3. I was at Eilat for the conference. The only info on dislay, apart from the weapons of course, were sacks of ‘made in Iran’ cement and some posters. The BBC reporter reported the speech, accurately as I recall, but in typical BBC fashion did no more. Why the evidence BBC Watch has provided was not on display I don’t know. I will blog the information you have highlighted as widely as possible.

    • A few sacks of cement can hardly be considered evidence. Read Gideon Levy’s editor in Haaretz.

      • Gideon Levi? lol why not read what White House spokesman said
        The United States intelligence services and military worked with Israel to track the Iranian ship carrying missiles to Gaza, which was apprehended Wednesday, according to AFP.

        White House spokesman Jay Carney said Washington started to work with Israel through intelligence and military channels and at the national security advisor level as soon as it knew the shipment was on the move.

  4. Pingback: » BBC News Reframes Iranian Arms Shipment Story, Censors Information

Comments are closed.