Will the BBC correct its insinuations of a ‘two-tier justice system’ in Israel?

On July 17th the BBC News website published an article titled “Three charged over Palestinian Mohammad Abu Khdair murder“.

The report relates to the fact that eleven days after their arrest on July 6th, three people were charged with the kidnapping and murder of Mohammed Ahu Khdeir on July 2nd.

The BBC’s report correctly notes that:

“The Israeli ministry of defence meanwhile said it now recognised the killing as a “terrorist act” and had decided to recognise Mohammad Abu Khdair as a “victim of terrorism”.”

It fails to inform readers however that the Defence Ministry’s decision means that the victim’s family will receive monthly benefits from the state and that Mohammed Abu Khdeir will be included in the list of names on Israel’s Memorial Day for victims of terror attacks.

Earlier in the month, during the four days which passed between the murder and the arrests, some BBC journalists promoted the notion of a ‘two-tier justice system’ in Israel, suggesting that Palestinians receive inferior treatment.

“… it was interesting as well – and telling, I think – to see the mother of the Palestinian teenager who was killed saying Palestinians have no rights and I think that they feel that there’s one law for Israelis and one law for themselves and that they’re never going to be in a better place until they get independence, get their own state and that, I think, is the prevalent view among Palestinians.” [emphasis added]

Jeremy Bowen, ‘Today’, BBC Radio 4, July 3rd 2014

“But Palestinians at Muhammed’s funeral don’t trust Israeli justice. They want Israel to leave Palestinian towns and cities so that they can build a state and a justice system of their own.”

James Reynolds, BBC News, July 4th 2014

It would of course be appropriate for the BBC to clarify to its audiences that its insinuations of Israeli state discrimination are unfounded. 

Advertisements

4 comments on “Will the BBC correct its insinuations of a ‘two-tier justice system’ in Israel?

    • How could it be true?!… Arab Israeli judges, prosecutors and defense councils are part of the system… There’s even an Arab Israeli supreme judge… And no, these are not “tokens”…

      Furthermore, if you think it’s true, please provide examples for your claim…

      • I’m saybing it’s TRUE (that the Israeli justice system is NON-biased ) – in reply to PieEater’s claim that it ISN’t true, which (in tiurn), was clearly set against the last sentence of the article: :”It would of course be appropriate for the BBC to clarify to its audiences that its insinuations of Israeli state discrimination are unfounded”.

        Didn’t you study Comprehension as part your English Language lessons at secondary school?

Comments are closed.