More BBC Balfour Declaration centenary reporting from Yolande Knell – part one

The BBC Jerusalem bureau’s Yolande Knell produced two similar reports – audio and written – concerning the Balfour Declaration centenary, one of which was broadcast on the BBC World Service radio programme ‘Newshour‘ on November 1st (from 14:06 here) and the other published in the ‘features’ section of the BBC News website’s Middle East page on November 2nd under the title “Balfour Declaration: The divisive legacy of 67 words“.

As has been the case in all the BBC’s coverage of the centenary (including a previous report by Knell), her portrayal of the document itself erased from audience view the part safeguarding “the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country” and no mention was made of the 800,000 Jewish refugees from Arab and Muslim lands.

In the audio version, Knell’s paraphrasing failed to clarify to listeners that the document specifically referred to the “civil and religious rights” of non-Jewish communities.

Audio: “…Britain pledged its support for a national home for the Jewish people in Palestine which, it said, shouldn’t prejudice the rights of existing non-Jewish communities.”

Written: “It stated that the British government supported “the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people”.

At the same time, it said that nothing should “prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities”.”

As was seen in additional BBC coverage, these two reports also promoted the notion of “competing narratives” without providing audiences with the tools to judge their validity.

Audio: “Our Middle East correspondent Yolande Knell reports now on how the Balfour Declaration is at the heart of two competing narratives.”

Written: “The British peer Arthur Balfour barely makes an appearance in UK schoolbooks, but many Israeli and Palestinian students could tell you about him.

His Balfour Declaration, made on 2 November 1917, is taught in their respective history classes and forms a key chapter in their two very different, national narratives.”

Both reports promoted Palestinian Authority/PLO messaging portraying the Balfour Declaration as the cause of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict but without adequate clarification of the fact that the conflict actually began decades before the State of Israel came into being and that the Arab riots of the early 1920s targeted long-existing Jewish communities in places such as Jaffa and Jerusalem.

Audio: “Meanwhile the Palestinians are planning protests and demanding an apology from the UK government. They see its historic decisions as the source of their unresolved conflict with Israel.”

“The Palestinian education minister Sabri Saydam says it [the Balfour Declaration] led to the modern conflict with Israel.”

Saydam: “We continue to remind our pupils of the pain that’s resulted from the Balfour Declaration, the misery the Palestinians continue to witness every day. The prolonging of the Israeli occupation is seen to be a by-product of the Balfour Declaration.”

Written: “It [the Balfour Declaration] can be seen as a starting point for the Arab-Israeli conflict.”

BBC audiences also found some debatable portrayals of history in these two reports – as will be discussed in part two of this post.

Related Articles:

BBC’s Bateman amplifies PLO’s Balfour agitprop

More Balfour Declaration agitprop promotion on the BBC News website

BBC News portrays propaganda installation as a “museum”

BBC report on UK Balfour dinner follows standard formula

 

Advertisements

11 comments on “More BBC Balfour Declaration centenary reporting from Yolande Knell – part one

  1. Pingback: More BBC Balfour Declaration centenary reporting from Yolande Knell – part two | BBC Watch

  2. Everything the British did after WW1 supported the Arabs.
    The British in 48 voted against recognizing Israel.
    In 1936 – as desperate Jews tried to flee Hitler, not a single visa was granted for them by the British in Jewish Mandate Palestine.

    From 1918 to 1948 the British didn’t give 1 inch of land to the Jews.
    The British on the other hand gave 77% of Mandate borders to the Arabs and named the country after the Jordan River. (Jordan). People forget Jordan was part of the British Mandate borders and its a country where no Jews are allowed to live

    The British also gave out a White paper in 39 barring all Jewish immigration to appease the Arabs.

    The British also sent some of their top soldiers like General John Bagot Glubb to help the Arabs in the 48 war.
    A very good article to read
    https://jtf.org/forum/index.php?topic=78273.0
    Uncovered: U.K. intel encouraged Arab armies to invade Israel in 1948Intelligence obtained by the French secret services in the Middle East sheds new light on Britain’s role in the Arab-Israeli War of Independence.
    By Meir Zamir
    Sep 14, 2014

  3. Pingback: BBC Radio 4’s ‘Today’ Balfour Declaration centenary special – part one | BBC Watch

  4. Pingback: 11/08 Links P2: Col Kemp: Israel as a Strategic Asset of the West; Morrissey: Israel haters are just ‘jealous’ of the country – 24/6 Magazine

  5. Pingback: BBC Radio 4’s ‘Today’ Balfour Declaration centenary special – part two | BBC Watch

  6. Pingback: BBC Radio 4’s ‘Today’ Balfour Declaration centenary special – part three | BBC Watch

  7. Pingback: BBC Radio 4’s ‘Today’ Balfour Declaration centenary special – part four | BBC Watch

  8. Pingback: MEMO Balfour event participant hosts BBC Radio 4 discussion on Balfour Declaration | BBC Watch

  9. Pingback: BBC WS ‘Newshour’ Balfour Declaration centenary special – part one | BBC Watch

  10. Pingback: BBC WS ‘Newshour’ Balfour Declaration centenary special – part two | BBC Watch

Comments are closed.