Snark and speculation on BBC Radio 4’s ‘Today’

The January 25th edition of BBC Radio 4’s ‘Today’ programme included an item (from 1:47:16 here) relating to an invitation extended two days earlier to two Israeli leaders to meet the US president in Washington.

The White House press secretary’s statement read:

“President Donald J. Trump will welcome Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel to the White House on January 28, 2020. LTG. (Res.) MK Benjamin Gantz, Blue and White Chairman, has also accepted the President’s invitation to come to Washington. The United States and Israel are strong partners, and the Prime Minister’s visit is an opportunity to discuss our shared regional and national security interests.”

On the same day the US Vice-president said:

“President Trump asked me to extend an invitation to Prime Minister Netanyahu to come to the White House next week for talks” on regional issues, including peace…” 

‘Today’ presenter Sarah Smith introduced the item as follows: [emphasis in italics in the original, emphasis in bold added]

Smith: “Donald Trump, using his usual humility, calls it ‘the deal of the century’: a proposed Middle East peace deal that he might be ready to unveil next week.”

As we have noted on these pages in the past (see for example here and here) when the BBC has promoted that highlighted claim, it is – as documented by AFP journalist Joe Dyke – unsupported and the hook for Smith’s snide reference to “humility” is actually a media generated myth. She continued:

Smith: “Jeremy Bowen, the BBC’s Middle East editor, will be there if he does. Good morning Jeremy. Some of the details of this came out of course via Twitter – being that this is President Trump – where he said ‘reports about details and timing of our closely-held peace plan are purely speculative’. But given that he put that on Twitter himself, that is presumably as good as an announcement that he’s ready to reveal it.”

In fact no “details…came out” at all via that one Tweet from Trump but Bowen was ready to play along with Smith’s speculations, adding more than a few of his own about possible elements of the US plan which he appears to have gleaned second-hand from the same Israeli media outlets which reported that Gantz would refuse the invitation to go to Washington. On the evening of January 25th, the accuracy of such journalistic speculations was evident when Gantz announced his intention to travel to Washington the following day.

BBC audiences learned nothing concrete or factual at all from Bowen’s repetition of speculations in unidentified “reports”. They did however see how the BBC is already framing this topic, portraying the as yet unpublished US plan as one “which will absolutely include all of Prime Minister Netanyahu of Israel’s agenda”.

So much for the BBC’s obligation to offer audiences “a range and depth of analysis and content not widely available from other United Kingdom news providers”.

40 comments on “Snark and speculation on BBC Radio 4’s ‘Today’

  1. Let me see we have numerous media outlets saying Trump says this could be the deal of the century. If it came av bout it would be true. Trump himself has never attempted to distance himself from the phrase.

    and of all the media outlets who gets criticized for using the phrase. the BBC. N other media site.


  2. Another chance to gorge oneself in a bowl of Bowen Speculative Fantasies for breakfast, is it not time he was put out to grass?

  3. It is very easy to say other media outlets have used this phrase. without doing it it is clearly implying it is only the BBC which is both misleading and inaccurate.

  4. Pingback: BBC Radio 4 listeners hear a context-free story from Jeremy Bowen | BBC Watch

  5. Pingback: BBC Radio 4’s preemptive framing of the ‘Peace to Prosperity’ plan | BBC Watch

  6. Pingback: BBC’s ‘Newshour’ serves up ‘rumours and leaks’ with one-sided analysis | BBC Watch

  7. Pingback: BBC Radio 4 news implies previous existence of Palestinian state in US plan report | BBC Watch

  8. Pingback: BBC radio interviews same PA representative three times in one day | BBC Watch

  9. Pingback: BBC WS radio promotes US peace plan commentary from partisan lobbying group | BBC Watch

  10. Pingback: A review of the impartiality of BBC radio coverage of the US ‘Peace to Prosperity’ plan | BBC Watch

Comments are closed.