BBC’s Donnison returns – with an old party trick

Hang on to your hats, folks! After an absence of over two months, Jon Donnison is back on the BBC News website’s Middle East page.

In the department of cutting-edge ‘Features & Analysis’ we find an item titled “From little Gaza to chunky Australia” which also appears in the ‘magazine’ section of the same website as well as having been broadcast as an audio piece in the August 10th edition of ‘From Our Own Correspondent’ which is aired on BBC Radio 4 and the BBC World Service. 

Donnison Australia Gaza

Sadly, those weeks of absence have not honed Donnison’s ability to produce accurate and impartial reporting. In an item comparing the size of the Gaza Strip to Australia which is apparently supposed to be whimsical or amusing, Donnison manages to squeeze in some of his tried and trusted old themes.

“With its wall, fences and watchtowers, Gaza is not a place for the claustrophobic.”

Does Donnison bother to go on to explain to his readers and listeners why there is a need for a wall, a fence and watchtowers? Does he make clear that the fence between Israel and the Gaza Strip (constructed between 1994- 96) is a product of the Oslo Accords or that the wall actually runs along the border between the Strip and Egypt? Of course he doesn’t: context would actually detract from the impression he is trying to create here.  

Donnison goes on:

“There are neighbourhoods with some of the highest population densities in the world.”

In the report’s written version that claim is accompanied by a handy graphic.

graphic donnison article

How lucky then that Donnison was not posted to Macau (population density per km2 – 19,416.29 in 2010), Monaco (population density per km2 – 17,703.5 in 2010), Singapore (population density per km2 – 7,252.43 in 2010) or Hong Kong (population density per km2 – 6,782.92 in 2010). Otherwise he would have had much more difficulty finding a convenient hook upon which to hang his agenda.

How fortunate too that the BBC’s former Gaza correspondent does not find himself in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem or any of the other cities mentioned below.

cities population density

And, coming as he does from Sheffield, Jon Donnison should definitely be aware of the fact that the population density of that city’s urban area is not too far behind that of the Gaza Strip (4,092 people per km2 in 2011) – making his “highest population densities in the world” party trick all the more passé. 

8 comments on “BBC’s Donnison returns – with an old party trick

  1. Well spotted Hadar. I was going to point that article out on a previous thread and mention some of those places that have a higher population density – you’ve done a better job than I would have!

    The photo accompanying the “From little Gaza to chunky Australia” piece showing a little girl enjoying a ride on a camel, presumably on a beach in Gaza, also exposes the lie of poor Gazans suffering in their “open air concentration camp”.

  2. Dear Hadar The BBC is beneath contempt, as is the Guardian, But they do immense damage by partial reporting of events. Do you know if your reports are read at the BBC? Best wishes Geoffrey Bernstein

  3. The top 10 most ‘crowded’ suburbs across Australia

    Didn’t someone say Australia has the worlds least population density?

    Suburb—Local Govt Area—Persons per km²
    1. Elizabeth Bay—Sydney—20,165
    2. Rushcutters Bay—Sydney—15,221
    3. Wentworth Point—Auburn—12,869
    4. Ultimo—Sydney—12,734
    5. Pyrmont—Sydney—12,458
    6. Darlinghurst —Sydney —11,651
    7. Milsons Point—North Sydney—11,701
    8. Surry Hills—Sydney—11,651
    9. Bondi—Waverly—11,162
    10. Potts Point—Sydney—11,128
    In case you have forgotten:

    Gaza Population Density 4,750 people per km²
    Gaza City Population Density 9,983 persons per km²

    Jewish Trivia
    Any Aussies reading this? Six out of the ten (6/10) places on the greatest population density list have a Jewish connection. Either like Bondi, they have a significant Jewish population or like Darlinghurst, house the offices of Jewish organisations. And the moral is …?

  4. Pingback: The Tripod: CAMERA Links in Three Languages – August 13th edition | BBC Watch

  5. Pingback: The Tripod: CAMERA Links in Three Languages | In Focus

Comments are closed.