BBC coverage of UK aid convoy fails to meet editorial guidelines on impartiality

As was noted in the comments to one of our previous posts (thanks to Duvid), a recent article from the Gatestone Institute highlights the promotion of extremist charities by the BBC.

“BBC’s leading current affairs program, Newsnight recently broadcast an eight-minute film in which a BBC reporter accompanied a British “aid convoy” headed to the most dangerous parts of Syria. […]

During the broadcast, the BBC did not, however, reveal the names of the charities involved with the convoy. The Aid for Syria Convoy is, in fact, managed by charities that many might justifiably regard as “extremist”: One Nation, Al Fatiha Global and Aid4Syria.”

Readers can see that ‘Newsnight’ broadcast here.

In addition to being featured on the BBC’s flagship news programme, a version of Catrin Nye’s report also appeared on the BBC’s Asian Network.

Catrin Nye BBC Asian network

Filmed and written versions of the report were promoted on Twitter and appeared on the BBC News website’s UK and Middle East pages.

Catrin Nye filmed website

Catrin Nye ME pge

Catrin Nye written website

There was also coverage on the BBC’s local TV (featuring one of the people mentioned in the Gatestone Institute report), on BBC World News, on BBC World Service radio and on Radio 4.

Catrin Nye BBC WS radio

Aid for Syria on BBC World News

As promoted on the Facebook account of one of the charities and on Catrin Nye’s Twitter account, further programming is scheduled for this coming weekend.

Aid for Syria FB

That, by any standard, is a great deal of coverage of one story. But of course the point – as made in the Gatestone Institute article – is that the BBC is telling half a story: in all of the above content it fails to inform viewers, readers and listeners at home and abroad of what lies beyond the humanitarian aid aspects of these charities, thus once again failing to meet BBC editorial guidelines on impartiality. 

“4.4.14

We should not automatically assume that contributors from other organisations (such as academics, journalists, researchers and representatives of charities) are unbiased and we may need to make it clear to the audience when contributors are associated with a particular viewpoint, if it is not apparent from their contribution or from the context in which their contribution is made.”

 

Advertisements

3 comments on “BBC coverage of UK aid convoy fails to meet editorial guidelines on impartiality

  1. Forgive me for asking an obvious question but is there any information of how many people actually read the bbc news reports. I, for example don’t even watch their terrestrial news programmes here in the UK. Are they really that influential? That’s not to diminish the wickedness of the bbc; that’s why I stopped both watching and paying for their propaganda. But, I’m interested to be educated on how significant they are in the global propaganda enterprise.

  2. Duvidl offers BBC Watchers this analysis of the BBC’s Catrin “the end is” Nye, in verse:

    Beebette Catrin “the end is” Nye,
    To Manchester says, “good-goodbye.”
    By caravan borne to Aleppo,
    Beeb’s own jihadi travel rep-o!
    She’ll take to jihad at its worst.
    Stockholm syndrome, like Patty Hearst.
    She’ll show Beeb’s travel rep-jihadi,
    Is not a goodie; she’s a baddie.

Comments are closed.