At BBC Culture website, audiences told Palestinians built Jerusalem

h/t FA

As British readers may know, for the past three years the BBC has been in “global partnership” with the Hay Festival. That means that BBC audiences see and hear coverage of that literary event across a variety of platforms and this year that included an episode of the programme ‘Talking Books’ which was broadcast on both the BBC News Channel and BBC World News on various dates during June.

“George Alagiah meets renowned writer and political commentator Ahdaf Soueif at Hay Festival.”

“George Alagiah meets renowned writer and political commentator Ahdaf Soueif at Hay Festival. Her latest book, ‘This Is Not A Border: Reportage and Reflection from the Palestine Festival of Literature’ is an anthology celebrating the tenth anniversary of her own extraordinary literary festival.”

The Palestine Festival of Literature – more commonly known as ‘PalFest’ – is of course an annual exercise in delegitimisation of Israel and promotion of the BDS campaign.

The ‘Talking Books’ programme is only available to UK-based audiences via BBC iPlayer but a clip from Alagiah’s conversation with Palestine Solidarity Campaign patron Ahdaf Soueif was posted earlier in the month on the BBC’s ‘Culture‘ website.

“Soueif is also a founding chair of the Palestinian [sic] Festival of Literature (Palfest). Her latest book, This Is Not a Border is a collection of writings from people who have appeared on the festival’s programme.

In this clip, Soueif reads from her own essay in the book, on the sanctuary of the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem. Watch the video above to see more of Ahdaf Soueif’s interview from the Hay Festival 2017.”

Those viewing that clip – which of course was specifically chosen to be promoted on the BBC’s ‘Culture’ website – hear the following from Soueif: [emphasis in italics in the original]

“…and I chose to write about Jerusalem because for the last four or five years we’ve really seen the push against and into Jerusalem becoming stronger and stronger. And at the heart of Jerusalem is of course the Dome of the Rock within el Haram al Sharif which is the sanctuary – Al Aqsa.

And it’s always…ever since I started doing this…the first time I went to Palestine in 2000 there was a moment when I walked into the sanctuary and I really, really felt…felt such a peace. I mean it’s such a beautiful space and throughout the festival I have really tried…wanted to give the visitors that sense…to give them that moment when you walk in and the world folds away. So I chose to describe the sanctuary and what it means and its history. And here is just the second paragraph in that piece which says –

A sanctuary on a hilltop. Around it the earth fell away. Palestinians are masters of terracing. They built Jerusalem on a hill and the Old City slopes gently towards the south-east; towards the sanctuary. And there, the central and biggest of 26 terraces is for the Dome of the Rock. From the south, 20 steps lead up to it. From the north, just nine.”

It is of course not in the least bit surprising to find veteran anti-Israel activist Ahdaf Soueif exploiting the wrapping of a literary festival for political ends. Predictable erasing all Jewish history from her portrayal of Temple Mount and using partisan terminology to describe the location, she promotes to Hay Festival goers and BBC audiences alike ridiculous ahistorical notions such as the idea that Palestinians built Jerusalem and the Dome of the Rock is situated on specially constructed ‘Palestinian terracing’.

However, the text accompanying this specifically selected clip does not include any factual information that would relieve audiences of those inaccurate impressions created by Soueif and it fails to adhere to existing BBC guidance on the use of terminology when describing Temple Mount and ‘Palestine‘.

Related Articles:

The Guardian, PalFest and the ‘culture’ of anti-Israel activism (UK Media Watch)

BDS-promoting Palestine Festival of Literature supported by British public funding (UK Media Watch)

Anti-peace BDS campaigner on judging panel of BBC Arabic competition

Mapping changes in the terminology used by the BBC to describe Temple Mount 





10 comments on “At BBC Culture website, audiences told Palestinians built Jerusalem

    • If it suits them, they will claim anything, including that Jesus was Palestinian, as was Moses. Of course we know why architectural digs never turn up anything inscribed in Arabic – these Palestinian-brand Arabs were still cutting each others’ heads off, on the Arabian Peninsula, while the Jews built Jerusalem.

  1. Too bad he wasn’t asked when, precisely, the “Palestinians” did the terracing to the Temple Mount? From historic photographs of the Dome of the Rock, it seems that they had a very hard time suppressing the weeds. Maybe that was a more difficult engineering task for them.

    • The terracing of the Temple Mount is believed to go back to Herodian times and demarcates the Second Temple.

      Agricultural terracing in the hills surrounding Jerusalem was introduced by Palestine Arab farmers in the relatively recent past, a few centuries ago. But the current Old City of Jerusalem was mostly built under Ottoman rule using Ottoman architectural styles and methods, not least the city walls.

      West Jerusalem was built by Jews, as was the rebuilt Jewish Quarter of the Old City and the new Jewish neighbourhoods of East Jerusalem. Most of the labour force in the post-1967 building boom was Arab, and much of the increase in the Arab population of East Jerusalem since 1967 (from 60000 to 400000) is a result of migration of construction workers, especially from the Hebron area.

  2. All a cog in the BBC’s wheel of wiping Israel off the map. You are wasting your time, Herr BBC, G*d is on Israel’s side.

  3. Pingback: 06/20 Links Pt2: Breaking the Silence and Immoral Equivalence; Exposing the Media’s Lies About Israel – 24/6 Magazine

  4. Not one intervention from Alagiah. Just enthusiastic applause. And the receptive audience taking it all in. I wonder whether there are PSC types among them. Some look rather familiar.

  5. The BBC is an enemy of the state of Israel and the Jewish people. A constant drip-drip of revisionism to make Jews appear alien in the land of Israel. I cannot wait until the day this scumbag organisation is brought down.

  6. The liberation of Jerusalem and the Temple Mount, as well as what we today call the West Bank (all three are referred to by the term “sanctuary” in the Bible), and their return to Jewish possession were prophesied to happen in 1967, in the Book of Daniel, chapter 8, verses 13-16, more than 2,500 years before that event occurred in history (the prophecy has been scientifically verified by Dead Sea Scroll C14 manuscript dating to be at least 2,000 years old) and a thousand years before Mohammed started Islam. The world watched the fulfillment of the prophecy during the Six-Day War. The book, Liberation of Jerusalem 1967, explains the prophecy, available as a free download in PDF format at:

Comments are closed.