Inaccuracy, reverse chronology and lack of context in BBC reporting on Gaza missile attacks

On the afternoon of August 8th terrorists in the Gaza Strip shot at civilian construction vehicles working on the Israeli side of the border.

“Shots were fired from the Gaza Strip at a number of civilian construction vehicles just outside the Palestinian enclave on Wednesday afternoon […]

In response, an Israeli tank shelled a Hamas observation post in the northern Gaza Strip, the army said. […]

The engineering vehicles that were fired upon are being used to build an underground barrier around the Gaza Strip, which is meant to counter Hamas’s network of border-crossing attack tunnels.

“Terrorists shot at civilian vehicles that were being used in the effort to construct the barrier around the security fence in the northern Gaza Strip. One vehicle was hit,” the Israel Defense Forces said.”

Just after 7:30 p.m. terror factions in the Gaza Strip began firing rockets and mortars at Israeli civilian communities near the border, two of which hit Sderot, causing shrapnel injuries to two residents. By 10:30 p.m. 36 projectiles had been launched, four of which were intercepted by the Iron Dome missile defence system. More residential buildings were hit overnight, as well as factories, in attacks claimed by Hamas and supported by the Palestinian Islamic Jihad.

The attacks continued throughout the night and by 6 a.m. the next day, over 150 projectiles had been launched, 25 of which were intercepted, with five civilians injured – one seriously – and some 14 others treated for shock. In response, the IDF conducted air strikes on terrorist sites in the Gaza Strip. The Hamas-run health ministry reported that three people had been killed – one a Hamas operative – and six injured in those strikes. At the time of writing, the attacks against Israeli civilians continue.

Over twelve hours after those missile attacks against Israeli civilians had begun, the BBC News website published a report titled “Israeli air strikes ‘kill woman and toddler'” on its main homepage, its ‘World’ page and its ‘Middle East’ page.

BBC News website homepage 9/8/18

Version 1

Following public objections to that context-free headline, two hours later the report’s title was changed to read “Gaza air strikes ‘kill woman and child’ after rockets hit Israel“.

Version 2

Despite the change of headline, the report still presented the story to readers in reverse chronological order, while failing to clarify that “Gaza health ministry officials” in fact means the terror organisation launching the attacks on Israeli civilians and portraying over 150 missiles as “dozens”. [emphasis added]

“Three Palestinians are reported to have been killed in a series of Israeli air strikes on the Gaza Strip, after militants there fired dozens of rockets into southern Israel.

Gaza health ministry officials said a pregnant woman and her daughter, aged one, were killed in the Jafarawi area.

A Hamas militant also died in the north, health officials said.”

Notably, the BBC was unable to give its audiences a similarly detailed portrayal of the injuries sustained by people on the other side of the border.

“Israeli media said several civilians were hurt by rocket fire in Sderot and other towns near the Gaza border.”

BBC audiences were told that:

“The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) said the violence broke out after militants shot at an IDF vehicle in Gaza on Wednesday.”

As BBC Watch pointed out to the BBC on Twitter, that sentence alone includes three inaccuracies.

The article’s last four paragraphs were copy/pasted from a report published two days earlier on the BBC News website and once again BBC audiences saw a tightly framed portrayal of the ‘Great Return March’ publicity stunt which whitewashes its violence and downplays the role of terror factions in its organisation and execution.

Related Articles:

BBC’s sanitisation of deliberate Gaza border violence continues

8 comments on “Inaccuracy, reverse chronology and lack of context in BBC reporting on Gaza missile attacks

  1. Elsewhere dozens, including children, have been killed by airstrikes in Yemen. Where’s the international outrage? When the Syrians were slaughtering Palestinians in the Yarmouk camp where was the interantional outrage. But when Israel responds to rocket fire, the BBC is in full-on outrage mode.

  2. I had logged on here to make exactly the same comment that I now see from gearyjoe, above. The BBC news at 1:00pm, a bulletin lasting just under ten minutes, covered the school bus bombing story from the 6:10 mark, for about one minute, according it less importance than the Boris Johnson “letterbox” crisis and the major story of the day, the abuse of children at the top Catholic school in the UK, which were the leads. Several other stories were covered before the Saudi-led airstrikes on the school bus.

    On the 6:00pm bulletin, the airstrikes story was item three, and the number of children dead was given as 29.

    Now imagine the shape of the news bulletins if that had been an Israeli airstrike on a terrorist camp, let alone if it it had been on a school bus. Can you even imagine the outrage?

    If the IHRA definition of antisemitism includes, as it does, holding Israel to different standards than eny other country, then the BBC news department is grossly antisemitic.

  3. The Jerusalem Post reports that the Israeli Foreign Ministry has accused the BBC of lying/misleading reporting of the rocket fire from Gaza and the IDF response, while the Israeli Embassy in the UK has filed a formal complaint to the BBC. See below:

    “….Foreign Ministry Spokesman Emmanuel Nahshon responded on Twitter: “Your title is deliberately misleading!!! Israel reacted following the launching of over 100 rockets at Southern Israel, targeting and injuring civilians. Change it immediately!!!”
    Emmanuel Nahshon
    6:30 AM – Aug 9, 2018

    An hour later, with the article unchanged, Nahshon tweeted that he is filing a formal complaint.”

    “This title is a deliberate misrepresentation of reality (that’s the polite equivalent of ‘this is a LIE’, if you don’t get it),” Nahshon wrote. “Israelis were targeted by Hamas and IDF acts to protect them. Change it IMMEDIATELY!!!” …”

  4. Pingback: BBC Radio 4 news bulletins mislead UK audiences on Gaza rocket attacks | BBC Watch

  5. Pingback: The Faulty Logic Behind the Attack on BDS – aladdinsmiraclelamp

  6. Pingback: More amendments made to BBC’s online Gaza rocket attacks report | BBC Watch

Comments are closed.